June 22, 2013

Echoes of Silence






At twenty-three years of age, one night in the Fall of 1965, (Jean-Claude Biette) disappears to escape military service, ordering André Téchiné to tell no one. His parents panic, his father visits the offices of the Cahiers, then a search through television, on the Leon Zitrone program. A letter finally arrives: from Rome, where he remained for four years. There he made four short films, two fiction (Ecco ho letto and La Partenza), two documentary (Attilio Bertolucci, Sandro Penna). In the process this leads him to the Pesaro Festival, where he makes ​​the acquaintance of Adolpho Arrietta. In Pesaro, along with Jean-Marie Straub, Jean Eustache and Bernardo Bertolucci (son of Attilio, the poet) he receives the shock of Echoes of Silence by Peter Emanuel Goldman....


— from Pierre Léon's new book Jean-Claude Biette, le sens du paradoxe



*

On Echoes of Silence (Peter Emanuel Goldman, 1965)

By Jean-Claude Biette





Recently banned by the French censors, Echoes of Silence seems to provoke the spectator not because Peter Emanuel Goldman shows a somewhat tarnished girl who sells herself to a fat old man, or a boy who caresses the chest of a male friend, or his hero Miguel discarding a girl with whom he no longer wants to make love — scenes that one could very well find again, complaisance aside, with many New York filmmakers; but because, pursuing faces obstinately, hesitating often from one to another, seeking the slightest traces of muteness even in dirty hands, grasped pieces of mirror, hair in disorder, Goldman pushes away the customary points of support, intrigue, clarified unfolding of a lived mixture, commentary by double exposure (sometimes only cartoons designate the situations), and so on.
The order and number of sequences seem to matter little, to us as to him; there exist two different prints of the film without one's being able to characterize them differently than by variations of duration and of lighting. It scarcely matter either that the musical sequences are repeated; they are there to prolong a state, as in the endless drawings-out, fishing for tuna or ascension, with Rossellini. Each chapter, or canvas, interrupts itself by virtue of continuing a length of time; the glances exchanged by three girls in a little room lead to nothing and keep within themselves, latent, a drama that does not unfold. To these beings lost in New York, nothing ever happens. A forlorn girl cradles a poor doll and nothing is resolved, one observes only an infinitesimal change. Here time is not accountable to the tumult of everyday life, and the film progresses by amplification, like a wave, slow but without return, not by the addition of actions or events whose exact path one seeks, but by the ensnaring joining of solitudes. If ever new faces appear, if one frequents surprising spaces -- like the museum — an ephemeral metamorphosis can be brought about; Miguel prowling through the museum, like Nosferatu, is suddenly caught in the circle of his motionless prey. But later when the phantoms will scatter in the streets of New York, scarcely distracted by the vehement reading of the Bible, for what reason would the film pace off the glimpsed desert?

                                    —  Jean-Claude Biette

From Cahiers du cinéma, no. 188, March 1967.
An English translation from Cahiers du cinéma in English, no. 11, Sept. 1967.

5 comments:

DavidEhrenstein said...

Whatever happened to Peter Emmanuel Goldman?

Andy Rector said...

You know, I don't know... I haven't even seen ECHOES OF SILENCE. One can dream.

But Goldman himself left a comment on this article on ECHOES:

Peter Goldman • - 3 months ago −
to Max Nelson: A friend of mine sent me your interesting review of Echoes of Silence, a film I did almost 50 years ago. When was it shown? Where? Strangely, there have been several articles about Echoes appearing this past year and Pip Chodorov of Re-Voir films in Paris is releasing Echoes, Wheel of Ashes and Pestilent City on video in the very near future. My email is mlinefilms@yahoo.com
Best wishes, Peter Emanuel Goldman

anissa pfannenstiel said...

I just met with Goldman last Friday. He is looking forward to Paris this fall where he will be reflecting on his past films and the release of these films on DVD, according to Goldman. I look forward to seeing these creative works.

Anonymous said...

Re:Voir just released two DVDs by Peter Emmanuel Goldman, "Echoes of Silence" and "Wheel of Ashes", both coming with bonuses.
They can be purchased from their website.

Andy Rector said...

Merci, Anonymous.

Archive